Real Reykjavik Restaurant Guide

By livingmywanderlust

Location: Reykjavik, Capital Region, Iceland

Discover Reykjavik's most authentic dining, from local cafes to unique restaurants, with this honest guide based on true experiences.

Overview

Intro

I’ve compiled this guide from my own experiences eating in central Reykjavík, focusing on spots where I actually sat down and tasted the food. The list includes a mix of cafes, casual local joints, seafood places, pizza spots, and bars to give a rounded idea of options. Use this guide as a quick reference for grabbing a casual lunch, finding evening dining options, or stopping by for a good coffee. It’s practical and focused on central neighborhoods where it’s easy to get around on foot. I keep prices realistic by sticking to what I encountered without guesswork. Each entry mentions a few things I ordered or enjoyed, offering a grounded sense of what to expect without lengthy menus or detailed logistics.

How to Get There

Intro

The easiest way to reach central Reykjavík from Keflavík Airport is by bus or shuttle service, which runs directly to the city center. Renting a car is an option too, especially if planning to explore beyond Reykjavík, though parking in the city can be tricky with limited street options and busy lots. Look for clearly marked public parking areas instead. Inside central Reykjavík, walking is very practical. Neighborhoods like downtown and the Old Harbour area are compact and pedestrian-friendly, letting you hop between cafés and restaurants easily. For short, quick trips, cycling or electric scooters provide a fun way to get around when weather permits, though they can be less reliable in winter or rain. Taxis and rideshares come in handy for late-night returns or when carrying heavy luggage. You’ll typically find taxi stands near popular spots and hotels, but booking a ride in advance can save time during busy hours.

Cafes and Coffee Breaks

Intro

The cafe culture here has a laid-back vibe, perfect for a slow coffee break or a quick caffeine fix. Reykjavik Roasters feels like a local staple; I go in the mid-afternoon when pastry freshness peaks and the shorter lines help snag a cozy seat. Ordering at the counter is quickest here, and it’s a great spot if you want to work or settle in for a while. Wake and Bake is my morning go-to since the early rush can clear out fast, making it ideal for a peaceful start. The staff breeze through orders from the counter, so it’s perfect for grab-and-go or sitting down if you catch the right moment. Te & Kaffi suits mid-morning visits when the crowd thins; the takeaway window makes it easy for those in a hurry. I find ordering at the counter helps with faster service, and there’s decent seating if you plan to linger. Sandholt stands out for a late-morning coffee with its fresh pastries and spacious seating. Walk in directly to avoid waiting, especially on weekends, since it’s popular among locals and visitors alike. Each of these spots offers distinct coffee runs, whether you’re after a sit-down break or a quick cup to fuel the day.

Casual Cafes

• Reykjavik Roasters
• Wake and Bake
• Te & Kaffi
• Sandholt

Local Eats and Unique Meals

Intro

Icelandic cuisine offers a variety of unique dishes that reflect the country's rich culinary heritage. Here are some local favorites you might consider trying: **Íslenski Barinn – The Icelandic Bar** This family-run gastropub is known for its authentic Icelandic dishes with a modern twist. A standout is the reindeer burger, offering a tender and flavorful experience. For a unique appetizer, try the smoked lamb on flatbread with bean salad. To avoid long waits, consider visiting during lunch hours. The atmosphere is relaxed and welcoming, making it a great spot to unwind. **Café Loki** Located near Hallgrímskirkja, Café Loki serves traditional Icelandic dishes in a cozy setting. Their rye bread ice cream is a must-try dessert, offering a sweet twist on a classic bread. For a hearty meal, the lamb soup is both filling and flavorful. To avoid crowds, it's best to visit during weekdays. The café also offers a selection of Icelandic breads and pastries, perfect for a light snack. **Bæjarins Beztu Pylsur** This iconic hot dog stand is a Reykjavik institution, known for its unique blend of lamb, pork, and beef sausages. A popular choice is the 'eina með öllu' (one with everything), which includes ketchup, mustard, remoulade, fried onions, and raw onions. It's a quick and satisfying snack, ideal for a late-night bite. Be prepared for a line, especially during peak hours, but the wait is worth it.

Where to Find Authentic Icelandic Flavors

• Íslenski Barinn - The Icelandic Bar
• Café Loki
• Bæjarins Beztu Pylsur
• Sægreifinn

Intro

For those seeking elevated casual dining experiences in Reykjavik, here are some noteworthy options: **Sægreifinn** Known for its fresh seafood offerings, Sægreifinn's lobster soup is a standout, rich and flavorful. Pair it with their skewers of grilled fish for a complete meal. It's a walk-in-friendly spot, but arriving early is advisable to secure a table. The casual setting makes it suitable for a relaxed dining experience. **Messinn** Specializing in fish dishes, Messinn offers a unique 'fish pot' experience, where various fish are cooked together in a flavorful broth. Their fish and chips are also highly recommended. Reservations are recommended, especially during peak tourist season, to ensure a spot. The modern ambiance adds to the dining experience. **Apotek Restaurant** Located in a historic building, Apotek offers a fusion of Icelandic and international cuisine. Their tasting menu provides a variety of flavors and is perfect for those looking to try multiple dishes. It's advisable to make reservations in advance, as the restaurant is popular among both locals and tourists. The elegant setting makes it suitable for a special evening out. **Lookoomas** A newer addition to Reykjavik's dining scene, Lookoomas offers a modern take on traditional Icelandic dishes. Their seafood platter is a highlight, showcasing the best of local catches. It's a walk-in-friendly spot, but arriving early is advisable to avoid waiting. The contemporary decor adds to the vibrant atmosphere.

Seafood Specialties and More

• Messinn
• Apotek Restaurant
• Lookoomas

Evening Bites and Bars

Intro

After a day of exploring Reykjavík, you might be looking for a spot to unwind with a late-night bite and a drink. Here are two places I visited that offer a relaxed atmosphere and satisfying options. **Lebowski Bar** This bar, inspired by the film "The Big Lebowski," has a lively vibe with a mix of locals and tourists. It's a great place to start your evening with a drink and then enjoy a meal. The menu features American classics like burgers and milkshakes. To avoid waiting, consider arriving before opening or sitting at the bar. For late-night options, taxis are available nearby, but be cautious when walking back due to the late hour. **Flatey Pizza** If you're in the mood for a late-night snack, Flatey Pizza offers a variety of pizzas in a casual setting. It's more food-focused, making it ideal for a quick bite. To minimize wait times, consider ordering ahead or arriving early. While it's a short walk from the city center, be mindful of the weather and dress warmly if you're heading out late. Both spots offer a relaxed atmosphere and are suitable for late-night dining. Whether you're looking to start your evening with drinks and food or just need a quick bite, these places have you covered.

Where to Unwind After Dinner

• Lebowski Bar
• Flatey Pizza